From: Karen Sides on behalf of Joseph Moore
Sent: Wednesday, July 11, 2007 10:54 AM
To: Alicia Gent; Ann Killets; Board Office; Gerald Williams; Joseph Moore; Joyce Beninati; Nat Harrington
Cc: Joseph Sanches; Carol Keller; Lisa Mead
Subject: 7-11-07 Board Meeting Question - Paulette Burdick - FY2008-2012 Five Year Plan -Construction

Importance: High

Attachments: Manatee_Elementary_07.pdf; ISSOC Policy.pdf; Draft BRHS Referendum Costs.pdf

On July 9th Board Member Paulette Burdick submitted the following requests regarding FY2008-2012 Five Year Plan -Construction

 

Request #1A. Please provide the OOD numbers at Manatee Elem.

 

Response #1A:    The out-of-district enrollment at Manatee Elementary for the last three school years is as follows:

 

SY2006-07      31

SY2005-06      38

SY2004-05      51

 

The Principal indicates that Manatee has three autistic units. The out-of-district students are comprised mostly of staff reassignments, in accordance with the CTA contract, and ESE assignments.  These OOD students provide the school with some diversity, which they do not want to lose. 

 

Request #1B:  Please provide a map marking any roadways or canals bisecting the PUD's in the attendance area.

 

Response #1B:  See the attachment labeled “Manatee Elementary 07”.

 

Please note Policy 5.01 states: "The integrity of subdivisions should be maintained. (NOTE: developments such as planned unit developments (PUDs) may consist of multiple distinct subdivisions.)"

 

Request #2:  Please provide the projects and budgets for the 5M for Boca H.S. referendum list.

 

Response #2:  See the attachment labeled “Draft BRHS Referendum Costs”.  Note that this is a draft because it will take more time to separate out the cost for the baseball field enhancements (Item 11) from the total cost of the baseball fields, and we do not have bids on some items such as the swimming pool (Item 4) and the playground shade covers (Item 13).  Some people may take the position that the District would have had to provide the additional classrooms (Item 1) for class size reduction, therefore the cost for that work should not be counted against the requested projects.

 

Request #3:  In May 06 the board approved a GMP for Village Academy for 14.3M including high school spaces but excluded the interior build-out.  Why is the budget being increased at this time?

 

Response #3:  In addition to excluding the build-out of the high school space, the budget that was approved by the Board excluded the completion of locker rooms.  The District was planning on completing the entire secondary school at one time, but during that time construction inflation was exceeding 20% per year and we did not have enough in the budget to build the high school and the locker rooms.  The draft FY 2008-2012 5-Year Plan proposes postponing the high school build-out for at least 5 years, therefore we are planning to complete the locker rooms for the middle and high school students that will be participating in sports over the next several years.  The cost to finish the locker rooms is $700k.  The middle school classrooms are nearing completion and there will be approximately $300k remaining in the project’s construction contingency.  We will need an additional $400k to finish the locker rooms.

 

Request #4:  Please attach the ISSOC policy.

 

Response #4:  See attachment labeled “ISSOC Policy”.

 

Request #5:  Please correct the (2) typo's for Gove Elem. A.) In 1989, 17 existing wooden portables were at Gove since that time 9 other wooden portables were relocated from other campuses. A 20 year employee at the school remembers the portables being at the school when she was first employed.  The capacity at the school was/is 658 and 300 seats provided by new concretables. B.)It appears that Gove is at 133% over capacity.

 

Response #5:  Staff has rechecked the FISH data and confirms that the capacity of the school is 924.  The school’s pre-CSR FISH was 936 and the CSR FISH was 780 prior to the addition of the 8 modulars which brought the FISH up to 924.  As per the Technical Advisory Group, which oversees school concurrency, modulars can be counted towards a school’s permanent capacity.  The wooden portables are not counted towards the school’s permanent FISH capacity of 924.  With a projected enrollment of 893 students the school’s utilization is projected to be 97% in SY 2007/2008 and only go up to 101% in SY 2011/2012. 

 

Staff noted that there was an error on the Board backup labeled “Summary of Changes”.  The Gove Elementary Modernization is not proposed to be postponed, however, Glade View Elementary is proposed to be postponed one year.  These schools are close to each other and staff’s plan is modernize Gove Elementary one year, and move Glade View into the old Gove for one year while we modernize Glade View.  This will save the District a considerable amount of money by avoiding the cost of demucking for and installing relocatable classrooms to temporarily house the students of at least one of the two schools. 

 

Request #6:  I appreciate the point system for ranking priority projects. Please run a new report with "reducing overcrowding" and assign it 12 points and "aging facility" with 8 point and referendum 10 points.

 

Response #6:  The points were determined by a cross-departmental group based on what they determined to be the ranking of the criteria.  These results were presented to and accepted by the Construction Oversight & Review Committee (CORC) and the Independent Sales Surtax Oversight Committee (ISSOC).  Before revising the criteria or the points and running different scenarios staff recommends that the rest of the Board have the benefit of hearing the presentation that was made to the oversight committees as well as the discussions that came out of those meetings.  Once that is done the Board may want to discuss the merits of the process and recommend adjustments.

 

Request #7:  Typo-Wynnebrook has been ranked above Gladeview and Washington. Please place it in the list along with Grove Park which has no instructional TV (old wiring), reoccurring IAQ and fire alarm problems.

 

Response #7:  Staff rechecked the 2003 rankings of the schools for modernization and Wynnebrook Elementary was ranked 5th which after Glade View (ranked 4th), but before Washington Elementary (6th).  Washington Elementary will be replaced with Wynnebrook on the next draft of the Plan.  The issues with Grove Park were considered when it was ranked 8th behind Washington Elementary and Hagan Road Elementary, which tied with a rank of 6th.   

   

Joseph M. Moore

Chief Operating Officer

561-434-8510